Skip to main content

Setting Good Social Change Goals: The Problem of Police Brutality

No one in the United States can say they are totally ignorant of the issues surrounding last week's death of Black Minneapolis resident George Floyd at the hands of a police officer. This post is not about the incident, which has been covered in great depth by others. This post is about setting goals to pursue in the wake of Floyd's high-profile death. 

What do protestors want, exactly? This is probably unknowable right now. Sure, they call for justice or for an end to police brutality, maybe in those exact words. Each one of those goals has a huge problem. Let's see why.

What does justice look like exactly? Will you know when justice has been served? Theoretically, some felony convictions for the involved officers would work. Right? Maybe. 

The goal of ending police brutality is far more problematic. How can we ever achieve a state of affairs where no cop ever abuses any suspect? That is what an end to police brutality might look like. Achieving perfection is a bit too ambitious. There must be other goals or objectives. 

Let's be S.M.A.R.T:

Maybe the current round of protests against racism and other issues can produce some concrete action steps and goals. Let's back up and review what a concrete goal is like. You may have seen the acronym S.M.A.R.T. but bear with me. 

A good racial justice goal has to be Specific, Measurable, Action-Oriented, Realistic, and Timely. We've seen that the goal of no police brutality anymore fails miserably. You can't end all police brutality. At least that goal is specific and measurable and action-oriented. What are some other options? What goals related to police conduct might be Specific, Measurable, Action-Oriented, Realistic, and Timely?

A Couple of Examples:

I had an idea earlier, an idea that seems to qualify as a S.M.A.R.T. goal. Perhaps citizens could pressure their state legislators to pass a law, like this one: 

All law enforcement officers work under a three-strikes rule for complaints of excessive force. On the third valid complaint, the officer is fired. 

The state shall have a similar law on the ballot or on the floor of the legislature in under 2 years from June 1. I think this is a decent example of what reformers can do now. 

I thought of another rule to do with extremist groups. This one falls a little short of being S.M.A.R.T but you can decide. What if state law allowed for firing police officers who belong to extremist groups like Proud Boys, Boogaloo Boys, White Aryan Resistance, KKK, and a wide variety of leftist groups that promote violence. 

Next time a social movement starts, take a minute to think about their goals. If they don't have specific, measurable, action-oriented, realistic, and timely goals then the movement might just be a waste of your time and energy. 

+++

If you want to get better results from your fundraisers, advocacy campaigns, or other social change efforts, I might be able to help. Shoot me an email (chesterdavisphd@gmail.com) 
or leave a comment.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How to Crowdsource and Experiment Our Way to a Fairer Economy

Economic and social inequality should be treated as design challenges that, like designs in architecture or packaging can be solved by applying some creative thinking. That's hardly a new idea, but the recession and ongoing concerns about economic inequality make crowdsourcing seem like something worth talking about.  Crowdsourcing as an Economic Justice Tool: Most people have an idea of what  crowdsourcing is and how it works - you let a group work on your problem or challenge and see what they produce. Can they produce a better answer (whatever that means) than an expert or a small group of experts? You can't answer that question until you have some real-world examples to draw upon. That's where social experiments and simulations can prove useful. Maybe there should be specific crowdsourcing projects and a place to organize all of them. We could start crowdsourcing campaigns around a range of topics: New ways of using barter to meet peoples' needs Using buying co...
Post a Comment
Read more

A Web Strategy That Works

I was reading a Chronicle of Philanthropy article about online strategies that work in a bad economy. The article presented four different strategies and a nonprofit that used it successfully. This post is about the strategy of using specialized Web sites. Put up a site just for a certain crisis, event, issue, project or program. The Chronicle details how Partners in Health did this for Haiti earthquake relief. Any issue, whether a crisis or not, whether global or local is a potential candidate for replicating the Partners in Health approach. Events of global and local significance are fine subjects for a site. You are probably already familiar with World AIDS Day or World Water Day. Those global events and many others are the subject of special Web sites and advertising campaigns both online and in print. Local events from the mundane, like the beginning of a new school year, to the momentous. A crisis is another good reason to put up a specialized Web site. The epic flooding in...
Post a Comment
Read more

Steering Your Brain Toward Better Program Ideas

This is a post about asking good questions whenever you think you have a good idea for a program or program improvement. You probably knew that great ideas still need to be examined, questioned if you please. That's what this post is about, sort of. Mostly, I want to offer a few comments on Brainsteering: A Better Approach to Breakthrough Ideas by Kevin and Shawn Coyne. Brainsteering offers a disciplined approach to asking, and answering, questions about product ideas and business ideas. The process also works just fine for program ideas. The book starts by describing some generic questions to ask about a challenge then goes into creating logic trees. A logic tree works by stating a question and breaking it down into subquestions. Simply asking and answering questions might lead to some valuable new ideas. Brainsteering And that's as far as I have gone in the book. I can say that there is a chapter on making your own brainstorming efforts more effective. Other chapter...
Post a Comment
Read more