Skip to main content

Speaking to the Concerns of Trump Supporters

If you want to promote social change, then you have to speak to the needs of your audience, speaking to the concerns of Trump supporters has to be part of that. Why? Marketing 101: Sell people something they say they need. You can create a need for universal basic income, a $15/hr minimum wage, or protection for LGBT workers. But, if your audience isn't interested in hearing about that, there's a huge problem. If you have a marketing team and $2 million annual communication budget, then maybe there's not much of a problem.

The following comments seem to apply mainly to political nonprofits, those that advocate for liberal or progressive policies. That would be correct. However, I think a wide range of issues can be framed in terms that speak to fiscally or socially conservative voters.

This Topic Dues Not Apply to My Organization:

I bet it does. Some nonprofits are about as nonpolitical as they can be, historic preservation organizations for example. Even if you would never even think of touching on national politics in your fundraising materials, there is probably some reason to look at the concerns of Trump voters. Depending on where you are, a third or more of adults voted for Donald Trump because they supported his message on national security, trade, jobs, immigration, and so on. Those four things probably swung the vote in Trump's favor for millions of voters.

This isn't a blog about political analysis, so I'll leave it at that. The point here is that Trump supporters are potential donors and may be constituents of yours without their even realizing it. Think of the situation as an opportunity: What does your organization do that overlaps with the interests of Trump voters?

You'll want to step back and answer a couple of more questions before that one though.

The Main Concerns of Trump Supporters:

I don't know exactly what they are, and I bet most communications people in liberal or progressive social change organizations don't know either. Unless I'm mistaken in your case, your first task is to look at what Trump supporters want. In a large nonprofit this might be a nationwide effort. In a city or in a region of a state you need to find out what area Trump supporters really want:

  • What are their priorities? 
  • What are their concerns about public safety, jobs, or whatever? 
  • What programs or resources do you have that might be relevant to one of those concerns?

I'm not saying your social services charity should start a crime prevention program just to mollify Trump supporters. Instead, what you could do is a bit more subtle, less resource-intensive, probably far more effective.

And never forget that everyone has the same basic values and interests - health, job security, family, financial security, a clean local environment, stuff like that. If your work is in any way relevant to one of those values, you have a built-in way to speak to the interests of socially and fiscally conservative individuals.

Finally, if you haven't yet subscribed to Chronicle of Philanthropy, consider doing so. This post was inspired by a recent article on the exact topic described in my title. If you are a subscriber the editorial I linked, will give you more ideas for speaking to Trump voters instead of simply attacking Trump and his policies. These tactics would appeal to your base, but kill any real chance you have of reaching conservative and moderate citizens.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Brainstorming for Fundraising Success

Looking for opportunities to raise more money or just to use your fundraising resources more efficiently? This post is another of a series on brainstorming and fundraising. You need three things to think creatively about fundraising. Openness to new ways of thinking is a requirement. Attitude matters in creative thinking, so you need to be positive and nonjudgmental. You also need to be familiar with one or more brainstorming tools. In recent posts I’ve described some brainstorming tools created by Edward De Bono and described in various books of his. In those posts I referred to using random ideas or objects to spark new ideas. In this post I will rely on a fantasy question, a provocation in De Bono’s terms, as a starting point. Consider this fantasy question: What if every donor supported 1000 charities? That question can potentially spark new ideas, if examined in the right way. De Bono writes about several ways of creating movement from a provocation like that question. I’ll qui...

Setting Good Social Change Goals: The Problem of Police Brutality

No one in the United States can say they are totally ignorant of the issues surrounding last week's death of Black Minneapolis resident George Floyd at the hands of a police officer. This post is not about the incident, which has been covered in great depth by others. This post is about setting goals to pursue in the wake of Floyd's high-profile death.  What do protestors want, exactly? This is probably unknowable right now. Sure, they call for justice or for an end to police brutality, maybe in those exact words. Each one of those goals has a huge problem. Let's see why. What does justice look like exactly? Will you know when justice has been served? Theoretically, some felony convictions for the involved officers would work. Right? Maybe.  The goal of ending police brutality is far more problematic. How can we ever achieve a state of affairs where no cop ever abuses any suspect? That is what an end to police brutality might look like. Achieving perfection is a bit too amb...

How to Think About Social Problems, Part I

Whenever a problem like gun violence or illegal immigration gains traction in the media, you'll find people misrepresenting the problem. The world is full of uninformed people, but the world is also full of dishonest actors trying to "sell" an idea. This post is the first of several where I will try to help the curious reader defend themselves from the fools and con artists and understand social problems, for real.  Confirmation bias is just the tendency to look for information that confirms what we already know or think. Everyone wants to be right, and the more important the subject is, the more the person wants to continue being right. Information that shows we're right gets more weight than information showing we are wrong. So, with that psychological note in mind, let's look at the outline of a formula for thinking about social problems.  Abusing Statistics - Raw Numbers A real thinker always gives numbers a context and always uses the right kind of numbers. A...