Skip to main content

Strategic Thinking and the Bandwagon Effect: Or Why the Effort Doesn't Always Match the Need

Unless things have changed in recent years, teen boys commit suicide and engage in high-risk behaviors at much higher rates than teen girls. For purposes of this strategic thinking post it doesn't matter why. Good strategic thinking only requires that those concerned about addressing the needs of troubled teens are really put most of their resources where most of the resources are needed.

This isn't always how things work out, and not only when it comes to preventing teen suicide and drug use.

The bandwagon effect is dangerous tendency to do what other people are doing, because that's what people are doing. I don't mean to imply that copying other organizations is a bad practice. Funding organizations like programs that seemed to have worked in other places at other times. Want to help keep kids out of trouble? Use the self-esteem and decision-making lessons that have been used in 255 other schools in recent years.

Even in such cases, copying isn't always a good idea. What if everyone is focused on teen girls while teen boys have at least as many issues? Sure, helping girls is good, but boys commit suicide at a much higher rate. The disparity continues while most of the money and volunteer time goes to helping girls navigate the emotional and psychological trials of adolescence.

In general then, the resources devoted to an issue should be proportional. Most of the money goes where most of the affected people are. Most of the free tuition offers go to the people who need the most help.

Someone who wants to start a program for troubled young people needs to consider where there is really a gap in services and support or where the real issues are. Don't just copy what others are doing, as a way to say that young people are "getting help".

Before you decide to start a new program or project ask if there are enough of those now? If not, then maybe you have found something important to do! Either way, try thinking of the issue in different ways:

Is suicide prevention the right focus?
Is low self esteem a contributing factor AND something that needs more attention?
What other factors that contribute to teen suicide are there and are they getting the attention they deserve?
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How to Crowdsource and Experiment Our Way to a Fairer Economy

Economic and social inequality should be treated as design challenges that, like designs in architecture or packaging can be solved by applying some creative thinking. That's hardly a new idea, but the recession and ongoing concerns about economic inequality make crowdsourcing seem like something worth talking about.  Crowdsourcing as an Economic Justice Tool: Most people have an idea of what  crowdsourcing is and how it works - you let a group work on your problem or challenge and see what they produce. Can they produce a better answer (whatever that means) than an expert or a small group of experts? You can't answer that question until you have some real-world examples to draw upon. That's where social experiments and simulations can prove useful. Maybe there should be specific crowdsourcing projects and a place to organize all of them. We could start crowdsourcing campaigns around a range of topics: New ways of using barter to meet peoples' needs Using buying co...
Post a Comment
Read more

Setting Good Social Change Goals: The Problem of Police Brutality

No one in the United States can say they are totally ignorant of the issues surrounding last week's death of Black Minneapolis resident George Floyd at the hands of a police officer. This post is not about the incident, which has been covered in great depth by others. This post is about setting goals to pursue in the wake of Floyd's high-profile death.  What do protestors want, exactly? This is probably unknowable right now. Sure, they call for justice or for an end to police brutality, maybe in those exact words. Each one of those goals has a huge problem. Let's see why. What does justice look like exactly? Will you know when justice has been served? Theoretically, some felony convictions for the involved officers would work. Right? Maybe.  The goal of ending police brutality is far more problematic. How can we ever achieve a state of affairs where no cop ever abuses any suspect? That is what an end to police brutality might look like. Achieving perfection is a bit too amb...
Post a Comment
Read more

A Technique for Generating Fundraising Ideas

I’ll return to the subject of strategic planning for nonprofits later. For now, I want to introduce another technique for generating ideas, for fundraising, planning, program design, advocacy, and other things. The Filament Technique was created by Edward De Bono, guru of creative thinking, and described in Serious Creativity . The technique is pretty easy to understand so I will just jump into demonstrating it with a nonprofit example. We start by defining a creative focus. In this case I want to focus to securing donations. You could also focus on fundraising generally or on another aspect of fundraising. The process is exactly the same. Having decided on the creative focus of “securing donations” I next need to list some of the normal requirements of securing donations. Here is my list: Potential donors Compelling case for donations Printed materials Objectives Note that those requirements are kept pretty broad. That was done on purpose. The list above is meant to be an illustrati...
Post a Comment
Read more